Almost every check-out comes down to one question: is this fair wear and tear, or is it something the tenant should have dealt with? Getting the answer right matters, because a deduction for the wrong thing is likely to be challenged — and cleaning is one of the most common reasons deposit deductions are disputed.
What fair wear and tear means
Fair wear and tear is the gradual deterioration that comes from a property being lived in normally: carpet flattening on a main walkway, paint fading in sunlight, light scuffs where furniture stood. It can’t be deducted from a deposit, because it would have happened however careful the tenant was.
Why dirt isn’t wear and tear
Cleanliness is treated separately. A property doesn’t become dirty through age — it becomes dirty because it wasn’t cleaned. The usual test is simple: the tenant should return the property as clean as it was at the start of the tenancy, as recorded in the check-in inventory. The length of the tenancy changes what counts as wear; it doesn’t change the cleanliness standard.
Where the line usually falls
- Carpets: flattened or faded pile is wear and tear; stains, pet odours and ground-in dirt are not
- Walls: minor scuffs and faded paint are wear; grease marks and adhesive residue are not
- Oven: worn door seals and faded markings are wear; burnt-on grease and carbon are cleaning
- Bathroom: ageing, discoloured sealant can be wear; limescale and soap scum are cleaning
- Windows: weathered frames are wear; dirty glass, tracks and sills are cleaning
Evidence decides it
If a deduction is disputed, the tenancy deposit scheme’s adjudicator looks at the documents, not at who sounds most convincing. A cleaning claim needs a check-in inventory that describes cleanliness room by room, dated photos from both ends of the tenancy, and an invoice or quote for the work. Vague wording such as “property clean throughout” is far weaker than a specific note on the oven, carpets and bathrooms.
Claim only what was lost
A deduction should put the property back to the standard at check-in — not improve it. If the oven was recorded as lightly used rather than spotless, the claim should reflect that. Claiming for the specific areas that fell short is usually more defensible than billing for a full clean when most of the property was returned in good order.
This is general guidance rather than legal advice — your deposit scheme publishes detailed guidance on deductions.
